Can the Buyer and Seller Use Different Title Companies in Maryland?

Yes. Maryland law allows buyers and sellers to select different title companies for the same real estate transaction, an arrangement known as a split settlement. Each party’s title company handles its own side of the closing — title search, title insurance, and document preparation — while coordinating with the other company to meet a shared closing date. Split settlements are legal, increasingly common, and manageable without delay when both title companies are experienced in coordinating across offices.

Real estate closings tend to follow a predictable rhythm. A contract gets signed, a closing date gets set, and most buyers and sellers assume the rest of the process will simply happen around them. But one question surfaces more often than people expect, particularly among investors, attorneys, and out-of-state parties: does the buyer have to use the same title company as the seller?

In Maryland, the answer is no. Nothing in state law requires both sides of a transaction to retain the same title company. Buyers and sellers are each free to choose their own provider, and when they do, the result is what’s known as a split settlement. It introduces a few additional coordination steps, but it’s a legitimate, well-established way to close on a property — and in some cases, it’s the smarter choice for everyone involved.

What Is a Split Settlement in a Maryland Real Estate Transaction?

A split settlement happens when the buyer and seller each retain separate title companies to manage their respective sides of a closing, rather than relying on a single company to handle the transaction from start to finish.

In a typical Maryland closing, one title company manages everything: the title search, the issuance of title insurance, the preparation of closing documents, and the disbursement of funds. In a split settlement, that work gets divided. The buyer’s title company — often selected based on the buyer’s lender requirements — usually takes the lead on the title search, title insurance policy, and overall closing logistics, since the buyer’s side carries the strongest interest in confirming clear title before funds change hands. Meanwhile, the seller’s title company handles tasks specific to the seller, such as coordinating mortgage payoffs, preparing the deed, and managing seller-side disclosures.

The two companies then communicate directly with each other to reconcile the settlement statement, confirm figures, and ensure both sides are ready to close on the same date. It’s a more collaborative process than a standard single-company closing, but it isn’t a fundamentally different one. Maryland’s recording and settlement requirements still apply in full; they’re simply administered by two offices instead of one.

Why Would a Buyer and Seller Use Different Title Companies?

There are several practical reasons buyers and sellers request separate title companies rather than defaulting to a single shared provider:

Existing relationships. A seller may have worked with a particular title company before and trust their process, while the buyer’s lender or agent recommends a different one based on their own prior experience.

Out-of-state parties. Maryland transactions frequently involve buyers, sellers, or investors based in other states. A party less familiar with Maryland’s settlement customs may prefer a title company with specific experience in their home state, even while closing takes place in Maryland.

Investor and attorney preferences. Real estate investors, attorneys, and repeat buyers often work with a preferred title partner across multiple transactions for the sake of consistency, pricing, and familiarity with their documentation needs.

Negotiated contract terms. Depending on local custom and the terms negotiated in the contract, the party responsible for certain closing costs — frequently the seller — may retain the right to select the title company responsible for that portion of the closing.

None of these situations are unusual, and none of them should introduce unnecessary risk to a transaction, provided both title companies involved understand how to coordinate a split settlement correctly.

Does a Split Settlement Slow Down the Closing Process?

Not inherently. The real risk in a split settlement isn’t the structure itself — it’s working with a title company that lacks experience coordinating across two offices. When both companies communicate clearly, confirm figures early, and understand Maryland’s settlement requirements, a split settlement can close on the exact same timeline as a standard, single-company closing.

Where delays tend to creep in is miscommunication: unclear ownership of tasks, last-minute changes to the settlement statement, or a title company unfamiliar with how to reconcile figures with an outside party. These issues aren’t unique to split settlements, but they become more visible when two companies are involved instead of one. Choosing a title company with a track record of coordinating split settlements — rather than one encountering the arrangement for the first time — is the single biggest factor in keeping the timeline intact.

What Each Title Company Handles in a Split Settlement

While the exact division of labor can vary by transaction, a typical Maryland split settlement follows this general structure:

The buyer’s title company typically manages:

  • The title search and examination of the property’s chain of title
  • Issuance of the lender’s title insurance policy and, if purchased, the owner’s policy
  • Resolution of any title defects, liens, or judgments uncovered during the search
  • Coordination with the buyer’s lender on closing conditions
  • Preparation of the closing disclosure and final settlement statement for the buyer’s side

The seller’s title company typically manages:

  • Coordination of the payoff for any existing mortgage or lien on the property
  • Preparation of the deed and other seller-side transfer documents
  • Confirmation of seller-side disclosures and contract obligations
  • Reconciliation of figures with the buyer’s title company ahead of closing

The two companies then align on a shared settlement statement, confirm that funds are accounted for on both sides, and schedule a closing date that works for everyone. In most cases, the actual signing can still happen at a single table, or remotely, depending on what the parties prefer.

When Does a Split Settlement Make the Most Sense?

A split settlement tends to work best in a few recurring scenarios:

When the buyer or seller is an out-of-state party. If an investor or seller based outside Maryland already has a trusted title relationship elsewhere, a split settlement lets them keep that relationship without forcing the other party to switch providers.

When an investor or attorney has a preferred provider. Repeat buyers often value consistency across multiple deals more than they value consolidating a single transaction under one roof.

When contract terms assign title company selection by cost responsibility. If the contract specifies that each party covers (and therefore selects) the title company responsible for its own portion of closing costs, a split settlement is often the natural outcome.

When one party has had a negative experience with the other side’s recommended title company. Rather than negotiating over which single company to use, a split settlement avoids the disagreement entirely.

A split settlement makes less sense when both parties are indifferent to their title company choice and a single, shared provider would simplify communication without sacrificing anything either side cares about. In those cases, a traditional single-company closing is usually the more efficient path.

What Buyers and Sellers Should Know Before Requesting a Split Settlement

A few considerations can help buyers and sellers avoid friction if they’re planning to request a split settlement:

Confirm your lender’s requirements early. Some lenders have specific title company or title insurance requirements that need to be addressed regardless of which company the buyer prefers.

Raise the request early in the contract process. A split settlement is far easier to coordinate when both title companies are identified at contract signing, rather than introduced midway through the closing timeline.

Ask about the title company’s split settlement experience directly. Not every title company coordinates these regularly. A company that handles split settlements often will have a clear process for reconciling figures and communicating with the opposing title company — one that handles them rarely may not.

Expect slightly more communication, not more paperwork. The core closing documents don’t change in a split settlement. What changes is the number of parties confirming those documents before closing day.

Clarify costs upfront. Each title company will charge for its own services, so buyers and sellers should understand which fees apply to their side of the transaction before closing.

How Armour Title Company Handles Split Settlements

Armour Title Company coordinates split settlements regularly for lenders, realtors, attorneys, investors, and homeowners across Maryland. Because Armour Title operates as a nationwide title company, we’re equally comfortable serving as the buyer’s title company working alongside an out-of-state seller’s provider, or vice versa — and our team understands the specific customs and recording requirements for Maryland title and escrow services.

Our approach to split settlements centers on direct, proactive communication with the opposing title company from the start of the transaction. That means confirming the settlement statement early, flagging any title issues as soon as they’re discovered, and keeping both parties aligned on the closing date — all with the fast turnaround Armour Title is known for. For a closer look at the broader scope of what a title company manages during closing, our recent post on what title companies do that you may not know about offers additional context on the work happening behind the scenes.

Whether you’re a buyer bringing in an out-of-state title company, a seller with an existing title relationship, or an investor managing multiple closings at once, Armour Title Company can serve as your side of a split settlement without compromising your closing timeline.

Ready to Discuss a Split Settlement for Your Maryland Closing?

Split settlements don’t have to complicate a real estate transaction. With the right title company coordinating your side of the deal, a split settlement can close just as smoothly — and just as quickly — as a standard closing.

If you’re a buyer, seller, lender, or attorney weighing whether a split settlement makes sense for your upcoming Maryland transaction, get a free title quote from Armour Title Company or contact our team directly to discuss how we can coordinate your side of the closing.